Margaritaville Island Hotel vs Nearby Hotels
Considering Margaritaville Island Hotel but want to compare other hotels nearby? These guides show how Margaritaville Island Hotel stacks up against popular alternatives.
Updated · 19 comparisons
All 19 Margaritaville Island Hotel Comparisons

Margaritaville Island Hotel vs Dollywood's DreamMore Resort
Margaritaville Island Hotel on The Island vs Dollywood's DreamMore Resort — Island social scene vs Dollywood-focused family resort.
Compare →
Margaritaville Island Hotel vs HeartSong Lodge & Resort
Margaritaville Island Hotel: island-themed hotel on The Island with rooftop pool and spa. HeartSong Lodge & Resort: newer Dollywood-branded family resort near Dollywood.
Compare →
Margaritaville Island Hotel vs Margaritaville Resort Gatlinburg
Compare Margaritaville Island Hotel (Pigeon Forge) vs Margaritaville Resort Gatlinburg — rooftop pool and Island access vs multi-pool downtown Gatlinburg resort.
Compare →
Margaritaville Island Hotel vs Historic Rocky Waters Inn, A Small Luxury Hotel
Margaritaville Island Hotel is a lively rooftop-pool resort at The Island; Historic Rocky Waters Inn is an upscale riverfront boutique in Gatlinburg.
Compare →
Margaritaville Island Hotel vs Hotel Cleo, Knoxville Downtown, a Tribute Portfolio Hotel
Margaritaville Island Hotel (Pigeon Forge) vs Hotel Cleo (downtown Knoxville): resort rooftop pool and spa vs boutique downtown convenience.
Compare →
Margaritaville Island Hotel vs Deer Ridge Resort by Jackson Mountain Rentals
Margaritaville Island Hotel (Pigeon Forge) vs Deer Ridge Resort (Gatlinburg): island entertainment and rooftop pool vs condo-style mountain rentals.
Compare →
Margaritaville Island Hotel vs Pigeon Forge Large Cabins
Margaritaville Island Hotel: island-themed resort on The Island with rooftop pool and onsite spa; Pigeon Forge Large Cabins: multi-bedroom cabins with private-pool options for groups.
Compare →
Margaritaville Island Hotel vs Gatlinburg Adventure Cabins
Compare a rooftop-pool, spa-forward resort on The Island with cabin rentals that offer private hot tubs and kitchens in Sevierville.
Compare →
Margaritaville Island Hotel vs Smith Creek Resort
Margaritaville Island Hotel: rooftop pool, on-site spa and Island access; Smith Creek Resort: multi-bedroom cabins with private pools and water-park access.
Compare →
Margaritaville Island Hotel vs The Pioneer
Margaritaville Island Hotel: resort on The Island with rooftop pool and full spa; The Pioneer: downtown Gatlinburg condo-style lodging.
Compare →
Margaritaville Island Hotel vs Smokies Motel
Margaritaville Island Hotel — 4-star island-themed hotel on The Island in Pigeon Forge with rooftop pool, spa and on-site dining.
Compare →
Margaritaville Island Hotel vs Tiny Home Village Near Dollywood
Margaritaville Island Hotel: rooftop pool, spa and walkable Island entertainment; Tiny Home Village: pet-friendly mountain cottages near Dollywood.
Compare →
Margaritaville Island Hotel vs The Resort at Dollys
Margaritaville Island Hotel: resort dining, rooftop pool and spa on The Island; The Resort at Dollys: budget, kitchen-equipped suites in Sevierville.
Compare →
Margaritaville Island Hotel vs Noir Manor
Margaritaville Island Hotel: rooftop pool, spa and on-site restaurants on The Island; Noir Manor: privately rented 3-bedroom Signature House with hot tub in Sevierville.
Compare →
Margaritaville Island Hotel vs A Top Notch Lodge
Resort-style Margaritaville Island Hotel on The Island vs private A Top Notch Lodge cabin in Gatlinburg — pick resort amenities or a private hot-tub cabin.
Compare →
Margaritaville Island Hotel vs Smoky Waters by Hosteeva
Margaritaville Island Hotel: resort hotel with rooftop pool and spa on The Island; Smoky Waters by Hosteeva: riverfront 2BR cabin in Sevierville.
Compare →
Margaritaville Island Hotel vs Wonderland Cove by Jackson Mountain Rentals
Margaritaville Island Hotel — a 4-star Island-front hotel with rooftop pool and spa; Wonderland Cove — a managed lakefront cabin near Douglas Lake.
Compare →
Margaritaville Island Hotel vs African Safari by Jackson Mountain Rentals
Margaritaville Island Hotel: rooftop pool, spa and island-themed dining on The Island; African Safari: Jackson Mountain Rentals villa near Dollywood.
Compare →
Margaritaville Island Hotel vs Little Bear by Jackson Mountain Rentals
Margaritaville Island Hotel — rooftop pool, spa and The Island access; Little Bear — Jackson Mountain Rentals cabin near Gatlinburg trails.
Compare →
Rooftop Pool & Chill Bar Access
- Lowest rate guarantee
- Complimentary perks & upgrades
- 24/7 concierge